Disclaimer: This post will be open and honest, my experience at the Ethiopian Heritage and Culture Camp. There were families there having a great time, connecting with other families/kids, learning and growing, etc. There were great classes and seminars, there were activities for children of all ages (although not really geared for toddlers). The staff and coordinators of the camp were sweet, loving individuals whose camp probably was awesome and perfect for a lot of families....it just wasn't for ours. Hopefully in a year or two, Mari and I will try again and be able to enjoy the camp.
Honesty time: We did not have a good time...it was not the place for my two-year-old to learn and grow. There were a couple of kids her age but they participated in activities and enjoyed themselves. Mari was stressed and hyper and clingy and overstimulated the whole time. I kept missing sessions or getting late to speakers because I had difficulty leaving my child with strangers. During the times that we were to do stuff together, she wanted to run off and not be with Mommy. During the times that there were activities for her to participate in, she wanted to be glued to Mommy. During one session, I left her with her group outside (in a large field flanked by woods and a parking lot with a small stream running through it), feeling uneasy as she was just kind of spacing out and not joining in. I even told the caregivers that she has a habit of wandering away and was told she would be watched. Luckily the class that session was in a lodge with big windows overlooking the field. I watched my daughter walk away from the group in the opposite direction from me, cross the stream, and start on into the parking lot. I can run fast when I need to! I took Mari back to class with me but it is hard to get anything out of a class when trying to keep a 2-yr-old quiet. During the campfire that night, Mari wanted nothing to do with singing or roasting marshmallows, she only wanted to get to the lake and see the duckies. (Natural for a 2-yr-old but not really safe at twilight)
Saturday, I had to leave her screaming again with the caretakers in order to make it to class. After that, we went to a family dance class where she made me hold her the whole time. So we scrapped that and went out to the Gebeye (market) they had set up outside and of course, she just wanted to run, run, run away from Mommy. I had to chase her into the woods at one point. So we went back to our car and got our nap stuff (lunch was still 2 hours away even though it was almost M's lunchtime), went into the main lodge and ate some go-gurt and snuggled up to watch Barney on our DVD player. Hot and sweaty and hungry and tired and cranky, Mari thrashed around restlessly while I checked the schedule. The pool was not open yet, lunch was not being served yet, I realized that I had already missed the one session I wanted to get to (Special Adoptions) and the ones in the afternoon were not as important to me.
It was then I took a serious look at things. My goals for the weekend were to have fun with Mari and learn some things for us to do together, connect with other families, and create some great memories. Both of us were miserable at that point. She was overwhelmed and stressed to the point that she really could not handle doing what was asked of her. I was overwhelmed and stressed because I felt like I was spending the whole weekend chasing and scolding and nagging and taking potty trips, etc. I think I could have learned some great things if I had been comfortable enough to leave her to go to the sessions (my mom even offered to keep her so I could go back by myself but I decided this is not what I wanted out of the weekend). And the connecting with families did not happen either. We did meet a few families and exchanged pleasantries but it was not the instant comraderie that I've grown to know in other situations where adoptive families get together. I honestly felt like families were competing to see who was doing a better job with "culture."
Panel of speakers
Mari not participating in one of the activities (she's just standing there wondering what the heck is going on). This is when I left her only to go running back out chasing her into the parking lot a few minutes later. Glad I dressed her in orange!
The one time she was truly happy...playing by ourselves on the playground.
The campfire that Mari wanted nothing to do with. That's Mari climbing over the bench in a mad dash for the lake.
Dear Mari, I'm sorry that I don't make you learn a set amount of Amharic words a day. I'm sorry that I do allow you to watch American television instead of Ethiopian television. I'm sorry that we do not cook Ethiopian food every day or talk on the phone with Ethiopians every day. I'm sorry that I'm apparently failing in your upbringing as an Ethiopian. I'm also sorry that my expectations for a great weekend made me forget that you are a normal 2-yr-old who is not ready for large crowds of unfamiliar people. You are not ready to be dropped off in unfamiliar places with strange people. You are not ready to have your whole schedule turned upside down and be expected to be happy and easy-going. Mommy will try harder to respect your needs and remember that great memories only come from having a great time together....it's not the place or the activities that make great memories. It's us. You and me. Doing ordinary things.
16 comments:
I have a question that I'm sure is exceedingly stupid, but maybe you can help me with it. :) First, I want to say that you didn't fail. All parents have these times and you handled it far better than some (you realized what was going on and did what you needed to do). You are a great mom and Mari couldn't ask for a better one.
Now, the stupid question, why is it so important that Mari learn Amharic and Ethiopian heritage? I know that she will appreciate those things later in life, but at this point, isn't having a mom who loves her the most important thing? I'm sure there is a very important reason that I don't know about since I have never gone through the adoption of a child.
Jill, I am so sorry your weekend wasn't a good one. You did not fail...if anone there made you feel that way then they are the failures! You are a great mom and your daughter will grow up proud of who she is and where she came from! So next year maybe we we will all meet up for a fun weekend at a zoo!
Oh, Jill...I'm sorry the weekend didn't go as you hoped. We all have times when we really feel like a failure. Then we recover and life goes on. Next time will be much better. We may just need to rethink our single moms gathering next summer because I'm quite sure Ruby would behave much like Mari and our weekend would turn out much like yours.
Kristina, your question is not stupid. And I was along the same thinking two years ago. I want Mari to be proud of her background and culture but it is up to her to embrace it or forget it. But until she is old enough and mature enough to make those decisions, it is my responsibility to expose her to at least some parts of her culture. There have been lots of studies done on internationally adopted children that show that forgetting their heritage and culture is directly associated with identity crises and feelings of grief and loss. One of the classes I did actually make it to this weekend spoke of adopted adults who, unable to find birthfamilies, were assuaged by making a connection with their birthcountry and culture.
I hope that it is enough just to love Mari and celebrate how special she is just for herself. But Ethiopia is a beautiful country and culture and, until she is old enough to chose how much she wants to embrace it, I want to make it available to her.
That's it in a nutshell (there is a whole lot more psych stuff I could go into, but I won't). The comments about not teaching her enough Amharic and letting her watch American TV instead of Ethiopian (which is not even an option around here!) were kind of facetious jokes. There were actually families that were complaining that they weren't doing enough because their preschoolers would rather watch American TV shows than Ethiopian or that they had only learned 4 Amharic words a day instead of the 5 that they had promised they would.
Good question...maybe I can come up with enough stuff to do a post on it.
Jill, you did the best you could and did not fail in any way... Nor should you be concerned with teaching Mari Eth languages and culture at this age. At 2, all she should know is her life story (simplified) and the name of her birth country along with some minor details. Anything else is overwhelming. My sons from India and Guatemala have grown into wanting more of their birth culture, the language, clothing, etc. We talk about it almost daily and our pride has naturally become theirs. It's a slow process and we can't bombard them.
If anyone at the camp implied you weren't doing enough, or expects parents to be doing all this it's their problem. Her adjustment and attachment to you are most important right now. Regarding other Ethiopians, find role models when she's a pre-teen if you can. Don't worry at age 2 because you're doing GREAT! And you're right-- it's not the elaborate 'activities' we do with our kids, but the little things that contain the most magic...those sacred little moments are all that matter.
Jill -
I want to say that I'm so thankful for this post. David and I were talking about making the trek to the camp next year. I really don't think I could handle a competition club.
Mari is blessed to have you for a mother. HER needs come first and you set a PERFECT example of that by leaving the camp early.
Silas is 4.5 and we don't practice insane amounts of amharic daily, he does have some Ethiopian videos he can watch if he chooses. Ultimately he's 4 and we do eat Ethiopian food as often as we can because he asks for it. He doesn't ask to speak amharic, in fact he reminds us he's American and speaks English if we do ask him.
All kids are different and making one feel badly for not having enough "culture" bothers me. Thats almost like labeling your children in a different way.
Also for an obviously adoption related camp I'm surprised they wanted you to leave your children with strangers. Maybe that just perplexes me but it seems like a bit more of a relaxed atmosphere would be better for all involved.
Thank you for your honesty, Jill. I always wondered if those camps would make us feel inadequate as parents who are trying to keep part of their culture alive in the kids. I think the bottom line is that Mari's going to grow up and be American. You shouldn't apologize-that's her life. And, it's wonderful for you to try to expose her to her culture and others who are in similar circumstances when she's ready for it.
Your honesty is refreshing. :)
I'm sorry your weekend did not go as planned and I hope that you can enjoy the camp together in a few years.
Jill, thank you for sharing your experience. You're not alone in dealing with the behaviors you described.
You're a great Mom.
Jill ... I'm so sorry that happened. Wow! I can't imagine how tough that must have been for you. I know that I wouldn't want to leave my child with strangers (not that I have a child yet), but I still wouldn't want to do it. I think that the most important thing is that you and Mari spend time together and that it shouldn't matter 'what' you are doing! You're not failing. Mari is flourishing and situational anxiety is something even adults have trouble with from time to time. Plus I don't even think that I would have stayed past the point of where they lost her & let her go in the parking lot! I would have been out of there! I think you are a great mom and you should relax and not put so much on your shoulders! Good Luck and like you said maybe in a few years and if not that's okay too!
Aww Jill. I'm sorry I missed you. I can understand how you felt. I only "connected" with a couple of families at the camp ( 3 or 4 to be exact). I totally agree with you that some of those folks were very stand offish, and not very friendly unless you were like them. So I basically just ignored them, and pursued conversations with folks that were genuinely interested in connecting with us. My 9 year old was not very entertained. I think I enjoyed it more than he did. So it definitely was NOT just Mari. My son didn't really want to go to any of the sessions because he didn't know anyone, and hardly anyone was his age. So he just hung out with me the whole time. (LOL) I'm sure that he would have behaved the same way if he was 2! He was just like your daughter. Maybe there will be a more "outgoing" group the next time.
I so appreciate this post. I have struggled with the same sort of issues and erred on the side of NOT participating in heritage camp with my two year old, thinking that it was just too soon. He seems very similar to Mari in so many respects (although he is from Viet Nam; his sister will be from Ethiopia). I feel the same type of responsibility you mention to keep his heritage accessible for him. It's daunting, but I'm finding that it's going to still be there in a year or two. I'm going to have to continue to reveal it to him slowly I suspect.
Please don't be so hard on yourself! You're not a failure, quite the opposite.
Thanks for sharing your experience at Mari's age. I had thought it might be a good idea when Sophia is 2 or 3. I know all kids are different. But I would think our daughter would have those same anxieties, just from seeing how she is with strangers at first. Poor Mari, for being stressed out. I think that giving them opportunities to embrace their culture is important, but Mari is always so darn happy. I think that is very important too!
Jill, you are a great mom. You put your child's needs first in a loving and wonderful way. All the ethiopian food in the world wont make her feel as loved as that will.
((Hugs))
Julie
p.s. I have had MANY 2 year old trips like this. She was acting very normal for her age. My kids never would have let me leave them at that age and they were not adopted. You did great!
Jill - I'm sorry this was such a crazy week-end for you guys. I think you handled it great & Mari was acting like a typical 2 year old.
The connection piece is one of the reasons I like going to places like this. It's frustrating when people seem to be competing rather than connecting!
You are doing awesome with Mari- you are doing an amazing job as a single parent - which isn't easy (holla!)
Jennifer
Jill,
You didn't fail at parenting. Unfortunately it sounds like you had a bad camp experience. We just returned from Heritage Camp at Mission Springs in California. I was a little hesitant about what camp would hold for us after reading your post last week. Unlike your camp experience, there was no one upmanship, activities were well organized for all ages and the speakers, families, kids were all awesome. My daughter is 4 1/2 and this age seemed to work well. I hope you give Heritage Camp another try when Mari is a little older and try the one on California if you can. Hannah really felt home at camp and gained so much in seeing families like hers, great Ethiopian role models and being able to learn about and experience her culture. Hope your next camp experience is better. You're a great Mom for trying to keep Mari in touch with her heritage.
Michelle
Jill,
I am so sorry that you had a bad experience at the heritage camp.
My children are older and while I was one of the organizers of the camp, i can honestly say that I let those with toddlers on the committee address those aspects of the camp. My focus was more on the adults and elementary aged kids.
I am so very sorry that the arrangements were not conducive to you and Mari having an enjoyable weekend. I'm sorrier still that no one thought to tell you to bring Mari along if she were having difficulty separating, and I am greatly disheartened that you felt it was a competition and no personal connections....Truly. I know we all felt rushed from one thing to a next and will endeavor to create more opportunities for parents and kids to socialize in upcoming events. We have also had a post-camp meeting to address making sure the kids are safe and secure and will implement changes on that level.
Mostly, I truly hope that you did not get a sense from any of the organizers that this was an effort to compare who parents the best! That was never on anyone's minds. Our goals were to provide an enriching experience to our families, and to make connections. If attendees left you feeling lacking, I am sorry, if organizers did so then we need to know because that is simply not acceptable.
peace,
carol, mom to 4 lovely girls, 2 from ET home 11/07 via aai WA State
feel free to email me at cab10735 at yahoo.com
Post a Comment